Teaching Practice · For teachers

How do you use a class sample without embarrassing students?

The short answer

Choose a sample for the thinking it reveals, then check whether classmates could recognise its author. Removing a name may not be enough. A clearly labelled teacher-created example can let the class discuss the same learning problem without displaying anyone’s work. Focus the discussion on a method, then check a fresh attempt.

Four things to remember

  1. Removing a name does not necessarily make a response unrecognisable.
  2. Use a clearly labelled invented example when real work adds unnecessary exposure.
  3. Ask students to explain and check the method, rather than judge its author.
  4. End with an independent task so you can see what the discussion helped students understand.

What makes a nameless sample recognisable?

A projected paragraph has no name on it, but it describes a family event the writer discussed yesterday. A photo of a calculation shows distinctive handwriting. A sentence repeats an unusual phrase that a student has just read aloud. In each case, classmates may recognise the writer even though the name has gone.

The OAIC’s de-identification guidance explains that removing direct identifiers alone may be insufficient: other information and the context in which it is shared matter too. Apply that general principle when choosing a classroom sample. Do not promise anonymity simply because you have cropped the heading. The guidance does not settle your school’s rules for using student work.

Start with the learning purpose. What will students notice in this particular response that they could not discuss in an example you write yourself? If the purpose is to examine a conversion error, you can often show the error without displaying a student’s page. If using real work is appropriate, follow your school’s process and check recognition risks before the lesson.

How should you choose and prepare the example?

Choose one point worth discussing: a missing explanation, an incorrect operation or a useful way of checking an answer. Avoid displaying a page full of unrelated difficulties. A small sample gives the class a specific decision to make and keeps the conversation focused.

For real work, consider more than the name. Look for personal details, handwriting, references to local events and wording that classmates already associate with someone. Retyping may remove handwriting, but it does not remove a recognisable story. If you cannot reasonably address the risk, choose a different sample or create a new one.

Do not ask a student in front of the class whether everyone may examine their mistake. Use the school’s agreed process in advance, including any required permissions and sharing limits. Permission to discuss work in a lesson should not be treated as permission to post it publicly or upload it to an external service.

Be honest about what you have prepared. Say “I wrote this example to give us a method to check” when it is invented. If you adapt work, do not present your changes as the student’s exact response. Keep the source distinction in your planning notes; students do not need an identifying backstory.

What original example can you use tomorrow?

The printable sheet provides this teacher-created task: “A strip is 240 cm long. Express its length in metres.” The invented response to check is: “240 cm = 24 m because I divided by 10.” No real student produced this sample. The incorrect answer is deliberate.

Introduce it with: “This is an invented example. Focus on the method, not a person. We need to decide whether the conversion preserves the length.” Give students these three prompts: What unit relationship do you need? Which step would you change, and why? How could you check your answer?

Let each student make a brief note before discussing responses. For students who need another way to show their thinking, accept an oral explanation, a diagram or a scribed response. The task assumes that students have met 100 cm = 1 m and division involving decimals. If they have not, teach those ideas before using this as a check.

This routine follows the broad formative-assessment principle described by AERO: gather evidence of understanding and use it to decide what to teach next. The task and teacher prompts are original classroom suggestions, not a tested intervention or an official assessment item.

What should the teacher listen for?

The calculation 240 ÷ 10 = 24 is arithmetically correct. The problem is the chosen conversion factor. Because 100 cm makes 1 m, divide 240 by 100 to express the same length in metres: 240 cm = 2.4 m. Multiplying 2.4 m by 100 gives 240 cm, which checks the conversion.

A student who says “move the decimal point” has suggested a procedure, but may not have explained why it applies. Ask what one metre contains and why the number of metres is smaller than the number of centimetres for the same strip. A sketch showing two whole metres and the remaining 40 cm can help make the units visible.

If students agree that 24 m is wrong but cannot supply the relationship between the units, return to that relationship. If they know 100 cm = 1 m but cannot divide 240 by 100, work on that calculation. These are different teaching needs; an identical wrong answer does not establish an identical cause.

Keep comments about the response concrete: “The division uses ten; the unit relationship needs one hundred.” Avoid “This person does not understand maths.” The first statement identifies a step to examine. The second makes an unsupported judgement about a person.

What if students start guessing whose work it is?

Set the discussion boundary before showing the sample: examine the reasoning, do not name or guess an author. If guessing starts, interrupt it without confirming an identity: “We are discussing this step, not who might have written it. What relationship between the units would help us check it?”

If a real sample has become identifiable or a student is uncomfortable, take it off the screen and move to a prepared invented example. Do not keep it visible while debating whether anyone should feel embarrassed. Follow up privately through your school’s usual support process where needed.

The same care applies to strong samples. A public example can invite comparisons with its author even when the teacher intends praise. Explain the feature worth learning from, and avoid turning one piece of work into a ranking of students.

How do you check learning after the discussion?

Hide the sample and give a fresh task: “A ribbon is 370 cm long. Express its length in metres. Explain your conversion and check it.” The answer is 3.7 m because 370 ÷ 100 = 3.7; multiplying 3.7 by 100 returns 370 cm. Ask for the explanation as well as the number.

A correct independent explanation gives you different evidence from copying the corrected sample. If a student gives 37 m, ask about the unit relationship before deciding which support is needed. If the explanation is sound but the calculation slips, address the calculation. Record the response and the support used rather than assigning a permanent label.

For a fuller sequence of modelling, guided practice and a new task, use the lesson on modelling revision without giving the answer. Here the main preparation decision is whether the class can examine a useful example without exposing its writer.

What should you record for the next lesson?

Use the planning record below to capture the learning focus, the source of the sample, your decision about recognition risk and the fresh task. Keep only the details needed for planning, in the school’s approved location. A public or shared planning sheet does not need a student’s name to explain why you chose an invented conversion example.

After the lesson, retain the prompt that helped students identify the relevant step. The feedback comment bank can help organise reusable wording, but select each comment after looking at the actual response.

If your department is exploring JeddAI, get in touch to discuss teacher review, suitable classroom workflows and questions about handling student work. You can also book a meeting below or create an individual teacher account.

Copy this class-sample planning record
Decision Example note
Learning focus Explain why centimetres are divided by 100 to express the same length in metres.
Sample source Teacher-created response; clearly labelled as invented.
Recognition check No real student work or personal details used. For actual work, check school process and context before sharing.
Discussion prompt Which unit relationship justifies the operation?
Fresh attempt 370 cm in metres, with explanation and a multiplication check.
Next teaching step Use the new response to distinguish a unit-relationship gap from a calculation difficulty.

Questions teachers ask

Is removing the student’s name enough?

Not necessarily. Handwriting, personal details or familiar wording may still identify the writer to classmates. Check the context and your school’s process. Use a different or teacher-created example if the learning point does not require displaying the real work.

Can I invent a response containing a mistake?

Yes, as a teaching exercise, provided you label it honestly and check both the error and the correction. This article supplies an invented conversion response and a teacher answer. Do not present it as evidence of what a real student or class did.

Should the class see the writer’s mark?

For this task, the mark is unnecessary. The discussion concerns a method and how to check it. Leave out information that does not serve that purpose, and follow the applicable school process for any actual assessment material.

Can I share the sample online after the lesson?

Treat public sharing as a separate decision. Classroom use does not establish permission for a website or external service. Check the school’s requirements and the intended audience; an original teacher-created example can often serve the teaching purpose.

About this guide

Written by Shashank Singhal and reviewed on 31 Oct 2026. Filed under Teaching Practice. Looking for study material? Browse Jeddle’s Australian-English study guides.

Keep reading

All teacher guides
Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!